Can an Appellate Court Dispose of an Appeal on the Basis of a Private Settlement and Add Non-Party Respondents by Consent?

The Calcutta High Court affirms the power to dispose appeals on settlement terms, add previously non-partied respondents who have affirmed affidavits, and grant liberty to amend pleadings—serving as persuasive authority in civil appellate procedure.   Summary Category Data Case Name MAT/717/2025 of SMARAJIT SAHA @ SUROJIT SAHA AND ORS Vs ASIT GHOSH AND ORS CNR […]

Can a writ petition be disposed of as infructuous once the petitioner’s grievance is redressed?

Calcutta High Court reaffirms that where relief has been granted by respondents, a writ petition may be summarily disposed of as infructuous, providing binding guidance on procedural finality in writ jurisdiction.   Summary Category Data Case Name WPA/16787/2025 of Namita Roy Vs State of West Bengal And Ors. CNR WBCHCA0341752025 Court Calcutta High Court Bench […]

Do minor discrepancies in eyewitness accounts and procedural lapses vitiate a conviction when supported by overwhelming medical and injured‐witness evidence?

Reaffirming that normal discrepancies, inquest limitations, and minor investigative omissions do not undermine murder and grievous‐hurt convictions; acquitting those not clearly implicated Calcutta High Court answers “No,” upholding convictions under Sections 302/326 IPC read with Section 34, acquitting one accused for lack of evidence. The judgment affirms precedents on inquest scope, normal vs material discrepancies, […]

Can Minor Discrepancies in Witness Accounts and Inquest Findings Undermine Convictions Under Sections 302/326 IPC?

Calcutta High Court affirms that minor contradictions, preliminary inquest reports and post-mortem meal-time estimations do not derail convictions; binding authority for handling injured-witness testimony and inquest scope   Summary Category Data Case Name C.R.A. 320 of 2015 Waser Sk. @ Wacher Mayra v. State of West Bengal CNR WBCHCA0273722015 Date of Registration 03-06-2015 Decision Date […]

Does the High Court’s writ jurisdiction empower it to direct administrative authorities to consider and dispose representations within a stipulated timeframe?

  Summary Category Data Case Name WP(C)/33311/2024 of MANJULATA MOHANTA Vs STATE OF ODISHA CNR ODHC010927152024 Decision Date 18-08-2025 Disposal Nature Disposed Off Judgment Author Mr. Justice Dixit Krishna Shripad Court Orissa High Court Bench Single Judge Type of Law Writ Jurisdiction / Administrative Law Questions of Law Whether the High Court can direct the […]

Can a Writ Petition Be Entertained When an Adequate Statutory Appeal Exists Under the O.P.L.E. Act?

High Court Reaffirms Exhaustion of Statutory Remedies Before Exercising Writ Jurisdiction in Eviction Proceedings under Section 12(1) of the O.P.L.E. Act The Orissa High Court held that where a clear statutory appeal remedy under Section 12(1) of the Odisha Prevention of Land Encroachment (O.P.L.E.) Act exists against eviction notices, the High Court will not entertain […]

Can a Writ Petition Be Dismissed for Non-Prosecution When the Petitioner Fails to Appear and Does Not Seek Adjournment?

Patna High Court dismisses petition for non-prosecution; underscores the procedural necessity of appearance or a formal adjournment request   Summary Category Data Case Name CWJC/16697/2011 of SHAMBHU KUMAR Vs THE STATE OF BIHAR and ORS CNR BRHC010292442011 Date of Registration 21-09-2011 Decision Date 01-04-2016 Disposal Nature DISMISS FOR NON-PROSECUTION Judgment Author Honourable Mr. Justice Rakesh […]

Can a Criminal Miscellaneous Application under Section 482 CrPC Be Withdrawn at Any Stage with the High Court’s Permission?

High Court permits withdrawal of quashing petition, reaffirming inherent discretionary power under Section 482 CrPC; persuasive authority for lower courts   Summary Category Data Case Name CR.MA/16575/2025 of Uttam Bhikhabhai Vansh vs State of Gujarat CNR GJHC240571592025 Decision Date 18-08-2025 Judgment Author Honourable Mr. Justice Nirzar S. Desai Court High Court of Gujarat Bench Single […]

Can bail under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 be refused when prima facie evidence shows serious economic offences and trial has commenced?

Calcutta High Court upholds established bail principles, binding on subordinate courts, affirming that overwhelming material and gravity of charges justify denial of bail under Section 483 BNS Sanhita   Summary Category Data Case Name CRM (M) 930 of 2025 of Bithi Ghosh Vs State of West Bengal CNR WBCHCA0288952025 Date of Registration 02-07-2025 Decision Date […]

When can bail be refused under Section 439 CrPC read with Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 for offences carrying mandatory life imprisonment?

Does the Calcutta High Court’s rejection of bail reaffirm the established principle that the nature and gravity of an offence and prima facie involvement justify denial of bail, and serve as binding authority for subordinate courts?   Summary Category Data Case Name CRM(M)/1079/2025 of Kazi Golam Khusbu Vs State of West Bengal CNR WBCHCA0324302025 Decision […]

Does a High Court Have the Power to Grant Liberty to Withdraw a Pending Bail Petition and Direct the Petitioner to Seek Relief Before the Trial Court Under Section 483 of the BNSS Act, 2023?

Calcutta High Court permits withdrawal of a bail application under Section 483, dismissing the petition as withdrawn while enabling the petitioner to approach the trial court   Summary Category Data Case Name CRM(M)/1036/2025 of ALI MAHBOUBI Vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL CNR WBCHCA0317512025 Decision Date 18-08-2025 Disposal Nature DISMISSED AS WITHDRAWN Judgment Author Suvra Ghosh, […]

Does failure to clear the written‐exam threshold bar a candidate from invoking reservation in promotion selections?

The Calcutta High Court reaffirms that reservation norms for promotional posts apply only after written‐exam qualification, distinguishes earlier Division Bench ruling and serves as binding authority for subordinate courts   Summary Category Data Case Name WPA/5157/2024 of SANGITA PRAMANIK (DAS) Vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. CNR WBCHCA0099412024 Date of Registration 23-02-2024 Decision Date […]