Can High Courts Dispose of Identical Writ Petitions by Following a Coordinate Bench Ruling?

  Summary Category Data Case Name CW/12522/2025 of Mahesh Kumar Mehar Son Of Shri Bajrang Lal Vs State of Rajasthan Connected with CW/12523/2025 of Lakhan Prajapat Son Of Shri Sohan Prajapat & Ors. Vs State CNR RJHC020712462025 Decision Date 19-08-2025 Disposal Nature DISPOSED OF Judgment Author Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mahendar Kumar Goyal Court High Court […]

Can a civil writ petition be withdrawn with liberty to refile only for petitioners appointed under a specific scheme?

High Court upholds limited withdrawal with permission to file a fresh petition for those appointed through the Rajasthan Medical Relief Society   Summary Category Data Case Name CW/12564/2025 of Om Prakash Lodha S/o Shri Mangilal Lodha Vs The State of Rajasthan CNR RJHC020687542025 Date of Registration 18-08-2025 Decision Date 19-08-2025 Disposal Nature WITHDRAWN Judgment Author […]

Does demonstration of sufficient cause justify condonation of a 102-day delay in filing a criminal appeal under Section 374(2) CrPC and Section 415(2) Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023?

High Court of Gujarat reaffirms its discretionary power to condone delay in criminal appeals upon sufficient cause, upholding existing precedent and providing binding guidance on procedural applications under the CrPC and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.   Summary Category Data Case Name CR.MA/16761/2025 of JAYDEEP @ JAYU UMESHBHAI PARMAR Vs STATE OF GUJARAT CNR […]

Can a High Court administratively transfer and dispose of writ petitions for statistical purposes pending roster assignment?

Administrative disposal and transfer under Articles 226/227 upheld; no prejudice to substantive hearing   Summary Category Data Case Name WP/32902/2024 of MUNIRAJA B M Vs STATE OF KARNATAKA CNR KAHC010694312024 Date of Registration 04-12-2024 Decision Date 12-12-2024 Disposal Nature DISPOSED Judgment Author HEMANT CHANDANGOUDAR Court High Court of Karnataka Bench Single Judge Bench Type of […]

Can Recovery of Excess Incentive Increments Be Stayed Pending Disposal of Similar Writ Petitions?

Interim Relief Affirmed in Educator Increment Recovery Dispute Madras High Court grants interim stay of administrative recovery, following its own prior orders in related petitions; persuasive for litigants seeking suspension of recoveries pending final adjudication.   Summary Category Data Case Name WP(MD) No.20736 of 2017 of K.KALITHAS vs The State of Tamil Nadu, CNR HCMD010632402017 […]

Can an Appellate Court Dismiss an Appeal for Non-Prosecution Due to the Appellant’s Casual Approach?

The High Court reaffirmed its inherent power to dismiss appeals where repeated adjournments and non-appearances waste judicial time, upholding existing procedural discipline and serving as binding authority on subordinate courts in appellate matters.   Summary Category Data Case Name FAO-2862-2019 of Suman and Another vs Naveen and Others CNR PHHC010386062019 Decision Date 23-07-2025 Disposal Nature […]

Can a High Court Exercise Its Inherent Power to Correct Clerical Errors in Its Orders?

Orissa High Court reaffirms its authority to rectify ministerial mistakes in judicial orders, guiding future correction applications   Summary Category Data CNR ODHC010019562016 Decision Date 24.06.2016 Judgment Author MR. JUSTICE DIXIT K.S. Court Orissa High Court Bench Mr. Justice Dixit K.S.; C.R. Dash, J. Facts as Summarised by the Court The petitioner pointed out that […]

Can a Contempt Petition Be Dismissed for Default When No One Appears?

High Court holds that absence of support leads to dismissal of contempt application for default   Summary Category Data Case Name CPAN 2005 of 2024 in WPA 8988 of 2023 Sudip Saha vs. Ayesha Rani CNR WBCHCA0604782024 Decision Date 27-03-2025 Disposal Nature Dismissed for Default Judgment Author Hon’ble Justice Shampa Sarkar Court Calcutta High Court […]

Can a High Court dismiss a writ petition for want of prosecution when the petitioner fails to appear?

High Court upholds existing practice affirming its inherent power to dismiss non-prosecuted civil writ petitions; binding authority for lower courts   Summary Category Data Case Name CWJC/4739/2016 of Poonam Devi Vs The State Of Bihar and Ors CNR BRHC010551432016 Decision Date 24-09-2018 Disposal Nature DISPOSED Judgment Author HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHIT KUMAR SHAH Court Patna […]

Can a promoted Junior Assistant claim retrospective selection grade pay under Rule 4(3) after the 2006 pay revision?

The Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court held that once an employee is promoted, entitlement to selection grade under Rule 4(3) and G.O.Ms.No.57 (Pay Cell-II) dated 28-01-1991 ceases after the 2006 scales revision embodied in G.O.Ms.No.234 (Pay Cell) dated 01-06-2009. The decision follows and affirms the common order in W.P. No. 21787 of 2014 […]

Should High Courts in Section 18 Land Acquisition Act Appeals Reassess Market Valuation or Defer to the Trial Court’s Discretion?

The Meghalaya High Court affirms the Special Judicial Officer’s enhanced land-valuation award, reaffirming that first appeals under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 must respect the trial court’s expert-driven valuation absent perversity. This judgment upholds existing precedent and serves as binding authority in subordinate courts and persuasive authority for other High Courts.   […]

Can a High Court Bail Petition under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita be Dismissed as Withdrawn at the Petitioner’s Request?

Calcutta High Court underscores that a petitioner-led withdrawal of a bail application under Section 483 BNS results in dismissal without merits examination, reaffirming procedural practice and binding on the parties involved.   Summary Category Data Case Name C.R.M. (NDPS) 684 of 2025 in Re: An application for Bail under Section 483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha […]